Professional Article Review

The article titled "CAD versus Sketching, Why Ask?" by James Self poses a very interesting view on design. In the article, the author goes around to universities and professional designers to get their opinions and test the different ways himself. After his experiences and research he came to a few conclusions,  one of them is that CAD is a very restricting program and limits what the designer can do based on the limitations of the programs own restrictions. He says that this could crush some designers hopes of making something creative due to not actually being able to 3d model it. The second point he makes is that while CAD can be restrictive, it has a better design structure for measurements and correct boundaries then doing sketches by hand. The third and final claim is that despite CAD and freehand having their own benefits and downfalls, combining the two when designing can be a very useful tool in seeing how exactly a sketch will look upon completion and allows for the digital transfer of files to producers or potential buyers. The author makes very strong claims and his research shows through in almost anything he ever says, which is really nice when comparing something common with something that is not so common like CAD. However, these claims fall short as he only talks about each claim for a brief period without anymore data or conclusions to say about them, which creates the idea that he doesn't really seem to have a real say on what the overall idea of both methods are. Personally as someone who has used CAD and programs similar to it, I find this article to be of a significant importance to me as I like to design things in my free time and have been looking to purchase software to do so. The author definitely knows what he is talking about and I will keep his advice and his research in mind when choosing a design software. Overall I think this is an interesting article that provides good information for anyone who is looking to design using CAD and/or by free handing.
Self, James. "CAD versus Sketching, Why Ask? by James Self." Core77. Core Jr., 2012. Web. 12 May 2016.